Every genuine voter who is excluded is as grave a wrong as a fake name that stays. But see who all are leading the “vote chori” campaign, they are the same lot who are corrupt to the core, looted public money, promoted criminals in politics and made corruption a non-issue in public discourse. True, past mistakes or crimes do not justify the current wrongs but let’s realise that what we are witnessing today is the outcome of corrupt and unethical and messy political culture perpetuated by every political party of all hue without any exception, writes former IAS officer V.S.Pandey
Theft is theft, whether it is from the public treasury, from citizens through illegal extortion, or from the people’s mandate. A political class that has plundered money for decades cannot be assumed to treat votes with more reverence. The real question is not whether vote theft exists. It is what those who held power did to stop it.
Booth capturing: the original sin: The first recorded case of booth capturing in India is traced to the 1957 general election in Rachiyahi village in Bihar’s Begusarai district. The practice spread since then across the country with booth capturing becoming widespread during seventies and onwards. During seventies alone, there were hundreds of cases of booths captured , ballot boxes snatched, many of them in Bihar and other northern states. In the paper-ballot era, criminals stockpiled illegal weapons before polling day, and polls in many places had to be cancelled and countermanded and repeated. That plunder which continued for several decades produced a generation of strongmen who eventually decided to contest elections themselves rather than work for politicians.
Electronic voting machines reduced the violence that is why the cry by many political parties to return to ballot papers era . Even after introduction of EVM’s ,the threat has not gone away. Instead culture of divisive politics based on caste , religion and black money has taken over now. Where scrutiny is weak and the system relies on paper, the old crime returns. That suggests the disease lies in intent, not in the machine.
Buying votes is also theft: Votes are stolen with cash as surely as with guns. Before the first phase of the 2024 Lok Sabha polls, enforcement agencies had seized more than Rs 4,650 crore in cash, drugs, liquor and freebies, the highest in the 75-year history of Lok Sabha elections. The Election Commission itself acknowledged that black money has distorted the level playing field. And what is caught is only the tip of the iceberg. The voter who sold her ballot for liquor, cash or a gift was robbed of her voice by those who exploited her poverty. Leading the race in this regard are the so called better administered southern states where distribution of money and freebies during the election times is rampant.
The candidate list is no less troubling. It is the culture of every political party to nominate only those as candidates who have tons of money and declared criminal cases against themselves, as they are considered winnable candidates and the result is that mostly crorepatis win the tickets of major political parties to contest elections. When aspirants to the law-making chair are themselves accused of breaking the law, who will uphold the rule of law?
The electoral roll fight: Today’s battle is over the voter list. On August 7, 2025, Leader of the Opposition alleged large-scale manipulation of the electoral roll in Karnataka’s Mahadevapura assembly segment. The Election Commission rejected the charge as baseless and asked for a sworn affidavit with names of wrongly included voters. Both sides owe the public something. Those who allege must produce proof, and those who investigate must be transparent. Slogans will neither save democracy nor reveal the truth.
The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) has redrawn the country’s rolls. Keeping the voter list honest and up-to-date by removing the dead, the migrated and the duplicate is necessary hygiene. Every genuine voter who is excluded is as grave a wrong as a fake name that stays. But see who all are leading the “vote chori” campaign, they are the same lot who are corrupt to the core, looted public money, promoted criminals in politics and made corruption a non-issue in public discourse. True, past mistakes or crimes do not justify the current wrongs but let’s realise that what we are witnessing today is the outcome of corrupt and unethical and messy political culture perpetuated by every political party of all hue without any exception.
Who is accusing whom? :It is fair to ask why, in Bengal and Uttar Pradesh, the accusations come from those who once controlled or are still controlling the entire machinery. Booth-level officers and all other layers of officials who prepare the rolls, are employees of state governments and work under the direct control of state governments. So the blame cannot be passed to the Election Commission alone. State governments and the Commission are both answerable.
There is also a pattern to notice. The party in power finds the system impartial. The party in opposition finds it crooked. A machinery that every party helped corrode is now being blamed by each in turn.
A rotten system cannot guard the ballot:When bribery runs from the police station to the tender room, from the ration shop to the registrar’s office, believing that only the voter list will be handled honestly is self-deception. This corruption did not fall from the sky. It was nurtured by leaders who spent heavily to win and recovered it with interest in office. Opaque election funding, cash donations, tickets for candidates with criminal records, and politics stoked by caste and religion: who built all this? Not the ordinary voter, but those who trade in the voter’s name.
The gap between what our leaders say and what they do is now intolerable. They preach honesty from the dais and run deals behind the curtain. Every demand for electoral reform is met with the same excuses: not the right time, no consensus. The public has seen through this trick.
Citizens no longer want promises. They want deadlines. From leaders of every party, the demands are clear- every citizen’s name should be on voter list, role of black money be eliminated, no party ticket for tainted and corrupt, freedom from caste and religion based politics.
Demands on leaders work only when voters are vigilant. Every citizen should check their name on the roll before an election, refuse cash or gifts for a vote, and reject the tainted candidate. Leaders change only when voters do.
Democracy cannot run on trust forever. The day public faith in elections is gone, neither ballot paper nor machine will save the country. Our leaders must wake up today. They must attack corruption at its root, end the flow of black money, and pull politics out of the swamp of caste, religion and crime. Those who refuse will not be forgiven by history, or by the people.
(Vijay Shankar Pandey is former Secretary Government of India)





